Skip to content
OddMaths
Back to Infinity & Impossible Mathsinfinity impossible

The Ant on the Stretching Rope: Can It Ever Reach the End?

A tiny ant crawls along a rubber rope that keeps stretching, and the end keeps running away from it. It feels hopeless, but the ant makes it, thanks to a sum that never stops growing.

An ant is racing a stretching rope, and the end keeps running away. You would bet it never arrives. You would lose that bet.

Here is the puzzle:

A rubber rope is 10 cm long. A very determined ant starts at the left end and crawls to the right at 1 cm every second.

At the end of each second, someone grabs the rope and stretches it evenly by 10 cm. The rope is 20 cm long after one second, 30 cm after two, and so on. Rubber stretches evenly, like taffy, so the ant gets carried along with the rope.

Will the ant ever reach the far end?

Have a guess. The rope grows by 10 cm every second, and the ant only crawls 1 cm every second. It sounds like the ant has no chance.

Stop and Think

Hint 1: Don't track the ant's distance. Track what fraction of the rope it has covered.
Hint 2: When the rope stretches evenly, does the ant's fraction change? If the ant is one tenth of the way along, where is it after the stretch?
Hint 3: How much of the rope does the ant cover in the first second? And in the second second?

Think in Fractions, Not Centimetres

Here is the trick. Stretching the rope does not change how far along the rope the ant is, as a fraction. If the ant is one tenth of the way along a 10 cm rope, it is still one tenth of the way along a 20 cm rope. The stretch just carries it forward.

So let's follow the fractions:

Second 1: the rope is 10 cm. The ant crawls 1 cm, which is 1/10 of the rope.
The rope stretches to 20 cm. The ant is carried to 2 cm, still 1/10 of the way.
Second 2: the rope is 20 cm. The ant crawls 1 cm, which is 1/20 of the rope. Total: 1/10 + 1/20 = 15% of the way.
The rope stretches to 30 cm, and the ant is carried to 4.5 cm.
Second 3: the rope is 30 cm. The ant crawls 1 cm, which is 1/30 of the rope. Total: about 18.3%.

Each second, the ant covers a smaller slice of the rope: 1/10, then 1/20, then 1/30, then 1/40...

The Surprise

Add up the slices and you get:

1/10 + 1/20 + 1/30 + 1/40 + ... = (1/10) × (1 + 1/2 + 1/3 + 1/4 + ...)

That is the same sum we met in the Achilles and the Tortoise article, the one that never stops growing, even though the pieces keep shrinking. It grows very slowly:

After 10 seconds: about 29% of the rope
After 100 seconds: about 52%
After 1,000 seconds: about 75%
After 10,000 seconds: about 98%

And it keeps going. The sum 1 + 1/2 + 1/3 + ... passes 10 after 12,367 terms. At that point the ant has covered 10/10 of the rope, which is all of it.

So the ant reaches the end during the 12,367th second, a little over 3 hours later. By then the rope is about 1.2 km long!

(We checked this by adding up the fractions one second at a time on a computer.)

So Why Does the Ant Win?

Because the ant's progress is measured in fractions, and the fractions never run out. Each second the ant gains a little more of the rope. The slices get smaller, but they shrink slowly enough that their total keeps growing without any limit.

Compare this with Achilles and the Tortoise, where the slices shrank so fast that the total stayed finite. Here the slices shrink more slowly, and that's the whole difference between "never arrives" and "arrives".

The Real (Ridiculous) Version

The classic puzzle uses a rope that is 1 km long, an ant that crawls at 1 cm per second, and a rope that stretches by 1 km every second. The ant still reaches the end. But now the sum 1 + 1/2 + 1/3 + ... has to grow to 100,000 instead of 10.

That takes about e multiplied by itself 100,000 times, counted in seconds (e is a special number, about 2.718). The answer is a number with roughly 43,430 digits. The universe is only about 400 quadrillion seconds old, a number with 18 digits. So the ant arrives in the maths, but not in real life. Unfortunately for the ant, there is nowhere near enough time (or rope!).

Try It Yourself

Check the fractions. After 4 seconds, what fraction of the rope has the ant covered? (Add 1/10 + 1/20 + 1/30 + 1/40.)

A shorter rope. Suppose the rope starts at 5 cm and stretches by 5 cm each second. The ant needs 1 + 1/2 + 1/3 + ... to pass 5. Roughly how many seconds is that?

No stretching. If the rope never stretched, how long would a 10 cm rope take? Why is the stretching version so much slower?

Check your answers: 1/10 + 1/20 + 1/30 + 1/40 = about 20.8%. For the 5 cm rope, the sum passes 5 after 83 terms, so the ant arrives during the 83rd second. And with no stretching, the ant crawls 10 cm in just 10 seconds. With the stretching, it needs about 12,367 seconds, because each second the ant covers a smaller and smaller share of the rope.

The OddMaths Takeaway

When the finish line runs away from you, don't count the distance. Count the fraction. The ant's fraction of the rope keeps growing without limit, so it must eventually reach 100%.

The ant is proof that a sum can grow for ever even when its pieces shrink. And it's a reminder to be careful before saying something is impossible.

🎯 Test Your Skill

One ant. One stretchy rope. Zero giving up.