Skip to content
OddMaths
Back to Infinity & Impossible Mathsinfinity impossible

Achilles and the Tortoise: Can a Fast Runner Ever Catch a Slow One?

A very old argument says a fast runner can never catch a slow one with a head start. Of course he can, so what's going on? The answer is that endless steps can add up to a finite time.

There is an argument, more than 2,000 years old, that says a fast runner can never catch a slow one. It sounds convincing. It's also wrong, and finding out why is a trip into infinity.

The story is credited to a Greek thinker called Zeno of Elea, who lived around 495 to 430 BCE. Here's a modern version:

Achilles, a champion runner, races a turbo-charged tortoise. Achilles runs at 10 metres per second. The tortoise zooms along at 1 metre per second. (It's a very special tortoise.)

The tortoise gets a 100 metre head start.

Can Achilles ever catch it?

Have a think. Does he? When? Where?

Zeno's Argument

Here's why Zeno said he can't:

Step 1: Achilles runs to where the tortoise started. But by then the tortoise has moved on a bit, so it's still ahead.
Step 2: Achilles runs to where the tortoise now is. But by then the tortoise has moved on again, so it's still ahead.
Step 3: And so on, for ever. Every time Achilles reaches the tortoise's old spot, the tortoise is a little further on.

Every time, the tortoise is still in front. So Achilles can never catch it!

Yet in real life, fast runners overtake slow ones all the time. Something is wrong. What?

Stop and Think

Hint 1: Use the numbers. How long does Achilles take to run the first 100 metres? How far does the tortoise go in that time?
Hint 2: Write down the next few gaps. Do you notice a pattern?
Hint 3: Zeno's story has infinitely many steps. Does that mean it takes infinite time?

Let's Follow the Steps

Let's do the sums for each of Zeno's steps.

Step 1: Achilles runs 100 m. That takes 10 seconds. The tortoise creeps 10 m. The gap is now 10 m.
Step 2: Achilles runs 10 m. That takes 1 second. The tortoise creeps 1 m. The gap is now 1 m.
Step 3: Achilles runs 1 m. That takes 0.1 seconds. The gap is now 0.1 m.
Step 4: Achilles runs 0.1 m. That takes 0.01 seconds. The gap is now 0.01 m.

See the pattern? Every step is ten times shorter than the one before. The steps get tinier and tinier, so Zeno is right that there are infinitely many of them. But look at the times:

10 + 1 + 0.1 + 0.01 + 0.001 + ...

Add those up and you get 11.111... seconds, and not a drop more. The time never reaches 12 seconds, never mind infinity.

Endless Steps, Finite Time

So there's the catch. Zeno's story really does have infinitely many steps, but each one takes less time than the last, so infinitely many steps can add up to a finite time.

We can double-check with simple algebra. Let t be the time Achilles takes to catch up. At that moment he has run 10t metres and the tortoise has run 1t metres, plus its 100 m head start:

10t = 100 + t
9t = 100
t = 100 ÷ 9 = 11.1 seconds (and he's 111.1 metres from the start)

Same answer. Achilles catches the tortoise after about 11.1 seconds, and then runs past it.

The Simplest Endless Sum

Zeno's argument falls apart because of a surprising fact:

½ + ¼ + ⅛ + 1⁄16 + ... = 1

Imagine a pizza. Eat half. Then eat half of what's left. Then half of that. You can keep going for ever, but you never eat more than one whole pizza, and you get as close to 1 as you like.

Here's a neat way to see it. Call the endless sum x:

x = ½ + ¼ + ⅛ + ...
Take away the first ½, and what's left is half of the whole sum: x = ½ + (½ × x)
So ½ x = ½, and x = 1.

If this reminds you of 0.999... = 1, that's no accident. They're two faces of the same idea.

Careful: Not Every Endless Sum Stays Small!

You might think that if the pieces keep shrinking, the total must always be finite. Not so!

1 + ½ + ⅓ + ¼ + ⅕ + ...

Each piece is smaller than the last, but this sum grows for ever. It does it very, very slowly: it takes 12,367 pieces just to get past 10. The pieces here shrink slowly enough that they never stop adding up.

So what matters isn't just that the steps shrink, but how fast they shrink. In Zeno's story, each step is 10 times smaller, and that is plenty fast.

Try It Yourself

A slower tortoise. The same race, but the tortoise now runs at 2 m/s. How long does Achilles take to catch it, and how far has he run? (Use the 10t = 100 + 2t trick.)

Thirds. What does ⅓ + ⅑ + 1⁄27 + ... add up to? (Hint: use the trick x = ⅓ + ⅓ × x.)

Pizza bites. You eat half a pizza, then half of what's left, then half of that, and so on. After 5 bites, what fraction of the pizza have you eaten?

Check your answers: with a 2 m/s tortoise, 8t = 100, so t = 12.5 seconds, and Achilles has run 10 × 12.5 = 125 metres. The thirds add up to ½. And after 5 bites you've eaten ½ + ¼ + ⅛ + 1⁄16 + 1⁄32 = 31⁄32 of the pizza, just 1⁄32 short of the whole thing.

The OddMaths Takeaway

Zeno's argument sounds airtight because "infinitely many steps" sounds like "it takes for ever". But it doesn't. When the steps shrink fast enough, infinitely many of them can add up to something finite, and Achilles gets to win the race.

Zeno's puzzles kept thinkers busy for centuries, and they're still a classic way into the idea of adding up infinitely many things. Next time you see a runner overtake someone, remember: you could chop that race into infinitely many Zeno steps, and it would still take a finite time.

🎯 Test Your Skill

On your marks. Get set. Infinity!