Next time you walk over a manhole cover, look at its shape. There's a good reason it's almost always a circle, and it's about maths.
The Puzzle
Manhole covers are heavy metal lids that sit on top of a hole in the street. The lid rests on a ledge just inside the hole, so the hole itself is a little smaller than the lid.
Now imagine a cover that's a square instead of a circle. Someone lifts it, turns it and... it drops straight down the hole. Ouch.
Why can a square cover fall in, when a round one never does?
Stop and Think
Hint 1: Measure a square's side. Now measure from one corner to the opposite corner. Which is longer?
Hint 2: A lid falls in if you can turn it so that it fits through the hole. A lid is only safe if it's too big in every direction.
Hint 3: Measure a circle across the middle in different directions. What do you notice?
The Circle: The Same Width Every Way
Measure a circle straight across, through the middle. That distance is its diameter. Now measure it in any other direction through the middle. It's the same every time.
That's a handy property. A circular lid is wider than its hole in every direction, so you can turn it, tilt it, twist it, and it can't slip through. There's no angle that makes it fit.
The Square: Longer One Way Than Another
A square is different. Take a square lid with sides of 60 centimetres. Measure the corner-to-corner diagonal:
Side: 60 cm
Diagonal: 60 × 1.414... = about 85 cm
The diagonal is about 1.4 times the side. So a square is narrower across than it is corner to corner.
Now suppose the hole is a square with 55 cm sides (a bit smaller than the lid, so the lid rests on the ledge). Its own diagonal is about 55 × 1.414 = 78 cm, which is longer than the lid's 60 cm side. So the lid can be turned on its edge across the hole's diagonal and slip through. That's the danger.
A square cover can be dropped in the wrong way round, and down it goes.
The Secret Name: Constant Width
A shape that measures the same width in every direction is called a shape of constant width. The circle is the most famous one.
There are some others. A Reuleaux triangle is a rounded triangle with curved sides, and it has constant width too, so it also couldn't fall down its hole. Mathematicians love it, because a shape that looks so different from a circle can still behave like one.
So Why Are Covers Round?
The "can't fall in" idea is one of the main reasons. According to Wikipedia, a round cover cannot fall through its circular opening, while a square one might if it's turned diagonally, and other shapes could work too. But there are good practical reasons as well:
A round cover is easy to make.
A round cover can be put back in any direction, so nobody has to line it up with the hole.
So the circle wins because it's safe, simple and easy.
Try It Yourself
Measure it. Take a sheet of A4 paper. Fold one top corner down so the short edge lies along the long side, then cut off the leftover strip below the fold. Unfold it, and you have a square. Measure the side and the diagonal with a ruler. How many times longer is the diagonal?
Circle check. Trace a circle around a cup. Measure it across the middle in four different directions. What do you find?
Safe or not? A rectangular lid is 80 cm by 50 cm. Could it fall down a hole that's a little smaller than the lid? Why?
Check your answers: the A4 square has a side of about 21 cm and a diagonal of about 29.7 cm, so the diagonal is about 1.4 times longer (that's the 1.414 from the square). Every measurement across your circle should be the same. A rectangle could fall in. Its width changes with direction (only 50 cm across the short way, but about 94 cm corner to corner), so it can be turned on its edge and slipped through a hole that's only a little smaller than the lid.
The OddMaths Takeaway
A circle looks plain, but it has a clever property: it's exactly the same width however you turn it. That makes it the safest shape for a lid that must never drop into the dark.
The next time you see a manhole cover, you'll know why it's round: a lid that can't fall through is worth a lot.