One cent, doubled every day for a month, is worth more than ten million dollars. And for most of the month, it looks like you got a terrible deal.
The Offer
A very generous (and very odd) person gives you a choice:
Offer A: $1,000,000 right now.
Offer B: You get 1 cent on day 1. On day 2 you get 2 cents. On day 3, 4 cents. Each day you get double the day before, and it goes on for 30 days. You keep everything you are paid.
Which one do you take? Think about it before you read on.
Stop and Think
Hint 1: How much do you get on day 10? On day 20?
Hint 2: Doubling means multiplying by 2 again and again. How big is 1 cent after doubling it 29 times?
Hint 3: Don't just look at one day. How much have you been paid altogether by then?
The Slow Start
Here is what happens in the first weeks (we worked out every row with a computer program):
Day 1: you get $0.01
Day 7: you get $0.64 (total so far: $1.27)
Day 10: you get $5.12 (total so far: $10.23)
Day 15: you get $163.84 (total so far: $327.67)
Day 20: you get $5,242.88 (total so far: $10,485.75)
After 20 days, you have collected about $10,500. Offer A is still miles ahead. If the deal stopped now, you would feel cheated.
The Explosion
Now watch the last ten days:
Day 21: you get $10,485.76
Day 25: you get $167,772.16 (total so far: $335,544.31)
Day 27: you get $671,088.64 (total so far: $1,342,177.27)
Day 29: you get $2,684,354.56
Day 30: you get $5,368,709.12
The running total passes one million on day 27. By day 30, you have been paid a grand total of $10,737,418.23. That's more than 10 times the million.
The Odd Part
Look at the last day. Day 30 pays $5,368,709.12. Everything you were paid on days 1 to 29 added up to $5,368,709.11. So the last day alone pays 1 cent more than the other 29 days combined.
That's what doubling does. Each new payment is bigger than everything before it put together. So half of all the money arrives on the very last day.
It's also why a deal that lasted only 26 days would be a disaster. The total would be just $671,088.63, which is less than a million.
What About $1,000 a Day?
Doubling beats steady payments, too. Suppose you were offered $1,000 every day for 30 days. That is $30,000 in total.
The penny plan's running total on day 21: $20,971.51
The penny plan's running total on day 22: $41,943.03
So by day 22 the penny has already overtaken the $30,000. It started with a single cent, and it wasn't even close by the end.
Why Is It So Hard to Feel?
Our brains are good at adding. Add the same amount each day and the total grows in a straight line. We expect that. But doubling is different: it multiplies, so the pile grows faster and faster. Between day 1 and day 30 the payment grows by a factor of 536,870,912, more than half a billion.
You can see the same effect in our article about folding paper in half again and again until the stack reaches the Moon. It's the same maths, in paper instead of pennies.
Try It Yourself
Next day. How much do you get on day 11?
A shorter deal. If the deal ran for only 25 days, what would your total be? Is it more or less than a million?
Your turn. Start with 1 cent and double it 10 times, writing down each answer. Which doubling first takes you past 1 dollar (100 cents)?
Check your answers: day 11 pays $10.24 (double the $5.12 from day 10). After 25 days, the total is $335,544.31, which is less than a million. Starting at 1 cent: 1, 2, 4, 8, 16, 32, 64, 128. The 8th number is the first one past 100 cents, so that's the first time you pass a dollar.
The OddMaths Takeaway
Doubling looks harmless at the start and then turns enormous. The penny deal beats a million dollars, but only if you can be patient: most of the money turns up in the last few days.
So next time someone offers you "just a little more each day", ask whether they mean adding or doubling. The difference can be worth over ten million dollars.