Skip to content
OddMaths
Back to Everyday Mathseveryday maths

Buy One Get One Half Price vs a Third Off: Which Deal Is Really Better?

'Half price' sounds like a much bigger bargain than 'a third off'. Work out what you actually pay, and the signs in the shop window start to look very different.

"Half price" sounds like a bigger bargain than "a third off". But when you work out what you really pay, the shop signs tell a different story.

Here's the puzzle. A shop is selling caps that cost $10 each, and there are two signs in the window:

Sign A: Buy one cap, get the second one half price.
Sign B: A third off every cap.

You want to buy two caps. Which sign saves you more money?

Have a guess before you read on. Most people pick Sign A, because half is bigger than a third. Let's see.

The Gut Feeling (and Why It's a Trap)

It seems obvious. One half is bigger than one third, so "half price" must be the better deal.

But look closely at what the half price is applied to. It's only the second cap. The first cap still costs the full $10. So "half price" doesn't cover your whole shopping. It only covers half of it!

What Do You Really Pay?

Let's do the sums for two $10 caps. Without any deal, they cost $20.

Sign A (second one half price): you pay $10 for the first cap and $5 for the second.

$10 + $5 = $15
You save $5 out of $20, which is 25% off.

Sign B (a third off): a third of $20 is about $6.67, so you take that off the whole bill.

$20 − $6.67 = $13.33
You save a third, which is 33.3% off.

So Sign B wins! "Half price on the second one" turns out to be only a quarter off the whole bill.

Your Shop Sign Decoder

Here's a cheat sheet for what the signs really mean. (Each one is worked out for however many items the deal needs.)

Buy one, get one free → pay for 1 out of 2 → 50% off
Buy one, get one half price → pay for 1½ out of 2 → 25% off
Buy 2, get 1 free ("3 for 2") → pay for 2 out of 3 → 33.3% off
A third off → 33.3% off
Buy 3, get 1 free → pay for 3 out of 4 → 25% off

Notice that "3 for 2" is exactly the same deal as "a third off". Only the wording is different.

Does Sign A Ever Win?

Never! Here's why. In "buy one, get one half price", the half price only goes on one item, and it's the cheaper one. The cheaper item can't cost more than half of the pair's total. And half off that is at most half of half: a quarter of the total.

The best "buy one, get one half price" can ever do is 25% off.
A third off is 33.3% off. It always wins.

This works whatever the prices are. We even checked a million random pairs of prices with a computer, and the saving never went above 25%.

It gets worse if you don't buy an even number. Imagine the caps cost $10 each:

Buy 1 cap → pay full price, 0% off
Buy 2 caps → 25% off
Buy 3 caps → only 16.7% off (just one pair gets the deal)
Buy 4 caps → 25% off

A third off gives you 33.3% off whether you buy one cap or twenty.

Try It Yourself

The T-shirt test. Two T-shirts cost $24 each. How much do you pay with "buy one, get one half price"? And with "a third off"? Which is cheaper, and by how much?

The free one. What percent off is "buy 3, get 1 free"?

The fair fight. Is "buy one, get one free" better than "a third off"? When might that not matter?

Check your answers: the T-shirts cost $36 with half price and $32 with a third off, so a third off saves you $4 more. "Buy 3, get 1 free" is 25% off. And "buy one, get one free" (50% off) beats a third off, but only if you really want two of them!

The OddMaths Takeaway

A discount can sound big without being big. The only thing that matters is how much you pay compared to the usual price, for everything you buy. Whenever you see a deal, turn it into a percentage: what do I pay, divided by what I'd normally pay?

Shops know that "half price" sounds better than it is. Now you know too.

🎯 Test Your Skill

Time to see if you can spot a real bargain.