Lots of people get this one wrong, and it's not because it's hard. It's because it looks too easy.
Here's the puzzle:
Your family drives to the beach. The roads are packed, so you crawl along at 30 km/h. On the way home the roads are empty, and you whizz back along the same road at 60 km/h.
What was your average speed for the whole round trip?
Take a guess before you read on. Many people give an answer in about two seconds.
The Quick Answer (and Why It Feels Right)
The quick answer is 45 km/h. After all, 45 is exactly halfway between 30 and 60. That's what averages are, right? Add the two numbers up and divide by 2.
It feels so natural that it's hard to see the problem. But there's something sneaky about speeds, and it's about time.
Stop and Think
Try these hints one at a time.
Hint 1: Imagine the beach is 60 km away. How long does the trip there take at 30 km/h?
Hint 2: How long does the trip home take at 60 km/h?
Hint 3: Average speed is the total distance divided by the total time.
Let's Do the Sums
Say the beach is 60 km away.
Going there: 60 km at 30 km/h takes 2 hours.
Coming home: 60 km at 60 km/h takes 1 hour.
Now the whole trip:
Total distance: 60 + 60 = 120 km
Total time: 2 + 1 = 3 hours
Average speed: 120 ÷ 3 = 40 km/h
So the answer is 40 km/h, not 45!
Why Isn't It 45?
Because you spent more time going slowly than going fast. The slow trip took 2 hours and the fast trip took only 1 hour. Two thirds of the whole trip was spent crawling along at 30 km/h, so the average gets dragged down towards the slow speed.
It doesn't matter how far the beach is, either. Call the distance d km. Going takes d ÷ 30 hours and coming back takes d ÷ 60 hours, so the whole 2d km trip takes d ÷ 30 + d ÷ 60 = 3d ÷ 60 hours. The average is 2d ÷ (3d ÷ 60) = 40 km/h, whatever d is. (With a 30 km beach, it's 1 hour there and half an hour back, which is 60 km in 1.5 hours.)
The 45 answer would only be right if you drove for the same amount of time at each speed, say 1 hour at 30 km/h (30 km) and then 1 hour at 60 km/h (60 km). That's 90 km in 2 hours, which is 45 km/h.
But the beach trip covers the same distance at each speed, not the same time. And that changes everything.
Try It Yourself
The big one. You drive 120 km at 40 km/h, then 120 km back at 120 km/h. What's your average speed? (Is it 80?)
The impossible one. You cycle to school at 10 km/h, uphill all the way. How fast would you have to cycle back home to average 20 km/h for the whole round trip? Take your time with this one.
Check your answers: the big trip takes 3 hours there and 1 hour back, which is 240 km in 4 hours, so the average is 60 km/h, not 80. And the school trip is impossible! Say the school is 10 km away (it works for any distance). To average 20 km/h over 20 km you'd need to finish the whole trip in 1 hour. But the trip to school already took 1 hour at 10 km/h, so you've used up all your time before you start coming home. No speed, however fast, can fix it.
The OddMaths Takeaway
Averaging speeds is a time problem in disguise. If you travel the same distance at two different speeds, you spend more time at the slower speed, so the average is pulled closer to the slow one. The right way is always the same: total distance divided by total time.
And the next time someone says "I was doing 30 there and 60 back, so I averaged 45", you'll know they're wrong by 5 km/h.