Skip to content
OddMaths
Back to Chance & Probabilitychance probability

The Monty Hall Problem: Why Swapping Doors Doubles Your Chances (Yes, Really)

Three doors, one car, two goats, and a game show host who opens a door to show you a goat. Should you swap? Nearly everyone says it makes no difference. Nearly everyone is wrong.

If you play this game show trick the right way, you'll win the car twice as often as everyone who doesn't. And the right way is the one your brain is screaming not to do.

Welcome to the Goat Game

Imagine a game show. There are three closed doors:

Behind one door: a shiny new car.
Behind the other two doors: a goat each. (Goats are lovely, but they don't fit in a garage.)

The game goes like this:

  1. You pick a door. Let's say door 1.\
  2. The host, who knows where the car is, opens one of the other doors. It always has a goat.\
  3. He asks: "Do you want to stick with door 1, or swap to the other closed door?"

Stop and think. Would you swap? Does it even matter? Make your guess before reading on.

Wait, It's Just 50/50... Right?

Two doors left. One car. That looks like a coin flip, and that's what almost everybody says.

In 1990, a famous magazine puzzle column ("Ask Marilyn" in Parade) said you should swap. Around 10,000 people wrote in to say she was wrong, and nearly 1,000 of them had PhDs (the super-high-level degree for really clever scientists). She was right and they were wrong.

By the way, the puzzle is named after Monty Hall, who really did host a game show called Let's Make a Deal.

The Sneaky Secret: Your First Pick Is Probably a Goat

When you first pick a door, what are the chances you picked the car?

1 in 3. And that means a 2 in 3 chance you picked a goat.

Nothing the host does later can change that. Now watch what the host does:

If you picked a goat (2 out of 3 times), the host can't open your door or the car door. He has to open the other goat door. So the door you could swap to is the car. Swapping wins!
If you picked the car (1 out of 3 times), the host opens a goat door, and swapping loses.

So swapping wins whenever your first pick was wrong, and that's 2 times out of 3. Staying wins only when your first pick was right: 1 time out of 3.

Still not sure? Count every possibility. The car could be behind any of 3 doors, and you could pick any of 3 doors, which makes 9 situations. Staying wins in 3 of them. Swapping wins in 6.

Try It: The 100-Door Madness

Okay, if three doors don't convince you, let's go big. Imagine 100 doors, with one car and 99 goats.

You pick door 1. Then the host, who knows where the car is, opens 98 doors, every one with a goat, and leaves just one other door closed.

Stick with your door: 1% chance of the car.
Swap to the last closed door: 99% chance.

Now it feels different, doesn't it? Out of 99 doors, the host carefully skipped one. He wasn't picking at random. He was dodging the car! That skipped door is very suspicious.

Play It Yourself (with Cups!)

You don't need a game show. Get three cups and a coin, and a friend:

  1. Your friend hides the coin under one cup.\
  2. You pick a cup.\
  3. Your friend lifts one of the other cups to show it's empty (they must know where the coin is!).\
  4. Play 30 rounds where you always stick, then 30 rounds where you always swap.

You should win about twice as often with swapping. We also had a computer play a million rounds: staying won about 33.3% of the time, and swapping won about 66.7%.

The OddMaths Takeaway

Our brains see two doors and say "50/50". But the doors aren't equal. The host knows where the car is and never opens that door, so his move hands you a clue. Your first pick stays a 1-in-3 guess, and the leftover door soaks up all the 2-in-3 chances.

One warning: the trick only works if the host always opens a goat door on purpose. If he opened a door by accident and it just happened to be a goat, it really would be 50/50.

🎯 Test Your Skill

Four questions. No goats were harmed.