On average, your friends have more friends than you do. Before you feel bad: so do everyone else's friends.
That sounds like it can't be true for everybody. Yet it is, and it's just a matter of counting.
A Tiny Town
Meet a town with 8 people. These are all the friendships (each one works both ways):
Ava is friends with Ben, Cal, Dee, Eli and Fay.
Ben is also friends with Cal.
Fay is also friends with Gus.
Gus is also friends with Hana.
Count how many friends each person has:
Ava: 5
Ben: 2
Cal: 2
Dee: 1
Eli: 1
Fay: 2
Gus: 2
Hana: 1
That's 16 friendship "slots" in total (every friendship fills two slots, one for each person). With 8 people, the average person has 16 ÷ 8 = 2 friends.
Stop and Think
The question: Now ask every person: "How many friends do your friends have, on average?" Will the answers be bigger or smaller than 2?
Hint 1: Whose name appears on lots of friend lists?
Hint 2: Look at Ava. How many people can say "Ava is my friend"?
Hint 3: Look at Dee. Who is Dee's one friend?
The Surprise
Let's find out. For each person, average the friend counts of their friends:
Ava's friends (Ben 2, Cal 2, Dee 1, Eli 1, Fay 2): average 1.6
Ben's friends (Ava 5, Cal 2): average 3.5
Cal's friends (Ava 5, Ben 2): average 3.5
Dee's friend (Ava 5): 5
Eli's friend (Ava 5): 5
Fay's friends (Ava 5, Gus 2): average 3.5
Gus's friends (Fay 2, Hana 1): average 1.5
Hana's friend (Gus 2): 2
Compare each person with their friends' average. Six out of the eight people have fewer friends than their friends do, on average. Only Ava and Gus come out ahead.
(We worked these out with a short computer program, to be sure.)
Why Does This Happen?
Think of those 16 friendship slots. Each slot holds a person, and the friend counts of those people are what get averaged:
Ava fills 5 of the 16 slots.
Ben, Cal, Fay and Gus fill 2 slots each.
Dee, Eli and Hana fill 1 slot each.
Popular people fill many slots. So when you pick a random friend, you are much more likely to land on Ava (5 friends) than on Dee (1 friend). That pulls the average up. Take the average friend count over all 16 slots and you get:
(5 × 5 + 4 × 2 × 2 + 3 × 1 × 1) ÷ 16 = 44 ÷ 16 = 2.75
Compare that with the plain average of 2. A random friend has 2.75 friends, but a random person has only 2. Nobody lied. Popular people simply get counted more often.
(This slot average, 2.75, is a different measure from the per-person answers above. If you average those eight answers instead, you get 3.2. Either way, it comes out bigger than 2.)
It's Not Really About You
Notice the paradox is about averages, not about every single person. Ava has more friends than all her friends. It's also not a rule that most people lose out. It happens when some people have far more friends than others, which is what real friend networks look like.
The American sociologist Scott Feld described this in 1991, in a paper called "Why your friends have more friends than you do". It works for any network where people have different numbers of links, including followers, phone contacts and the people you sit near at lunch.
Try It Yourself
A star. One person is friends with 4 others, who have no other friends. What is the average number of friends per person? What is the average number of friends of a randomly picked friend (use the slot method)?
Count your class. Ask every classmate how many friends they have in the class. Then ask each one to name all their friends, and write down how many friends each of those has. Which average is bigger: the friend counts of people, or the friend counts of friends? (In a small class, luck can twist the result, so the paradox shows best in a big group.)
Spot the popular one. In the Tiny Town above, who makes the average jump the most?
Check your answers: in the star, there are 5 people and 8 slots, so the average is 8 ÷ 5 = 1.6 friends. The slots hold the centre (4 friends) four times and each of the 4 others (1 friend) once, so the slot average is (4 × 4 + 4 × 1) ÷ 8 = 2.5. In Tiny Town, Ava pulls the average up, because she is in 5 friend lists.
The OddMaths Takeaway
Averages hide who gets counted more. If you pick friends instead of people, the popular ones show up more often, and the average goes up.
So if your friends seem to have more friends than you, you're not unlucky. You're just on the wrong side of the way averages work.