Skip to content
OddMaths
Back to Puzzlespuzzles

The Torch and Bridge Puzzle: Why the Obvious Plan Isn't the Fastest

Four friends must cross a wobbly bridge at night with one torch, two at a time. The obvious plan takes 19 minutes, but a cleverer plan takes 17, and the trick is to send the two slowest walkers together.

Four friends, one torch and one wobbly bridge. Almost everybody picks the same plan, and it's not the best one.

The Puzzle

It's the middle of the night. Four friends need to cross a narrow rope bridge, and they have one torch between them. Here are the rules:

The bridge holds only two people at a time.
Anyone on the bridge must carry the torch, because it's far too dark to cross without it.
The torch can't be thrown. Someone has to walk it back each time.
When two people cross together, they walk at the slower person's speed.

The four friends walk at different speeds. This is how long each one needs to cross the bridge on their own:

Rocket: 1 minute (takes the stairs two at a time)
Jogger: 2 minutes
Walker: 5 minutes
Wanderer: 10 minutes (stops to look at every flower)

What is the fastest way to get all four friends across?

Stop and Think

Have a go before you read on. Draw a bridge on paper, make four little tokens and move them about.

Hint 1: Try the plan that feels most natural first. Add up the minutes.
Hint 2: Somebody has to bring the torch back each time. Who should that be?
Hint 3: The slowest walkers are the real problem. Could they cross together, so their slow times overlap?

The Obvious Plan: 19 Minutes

The most natural idea is to let the fastest friend, Rocket, be the torch carrier. Rocket takes each friend across, then runs back.

1. Rocket and Jogger cross: 2 minutes
2. Rocket runs back: 1 minute
3. Rocket and Walker cross: 5 minutes
4. Rocket runs back: 1 minute
5. Rocket and Wanderer cross: 10 minutes

Total: 2 + 1 + 5 + 1 + 10 = 19 minutes.

That feels sensible. But there's a cleverer way.

The Better Plan: 17 Minutes

The clever idea is to send the two slowest friends across at the same time.

1. Rocket and Jogger cross: 2 minutes
2. Rocket runs back with the torch: 1 minute
3. Walker and Wanderer cross together: 10 minutes
4. Jogger (waiting on the far side) brings the torch back: 2 minutes
5. Rocket and Jogger cross again: 2 minutes

Total: 2 + 1 + 10 + 2 + 2 = 17 minutes.

Two minutes saved! Walker's 5 minutes vanished, because Walker walks along with Wanderer, and the pair only takes 10.

Is 17 the Best?

Yes. We asked a computer to try every possible way of getting the four friends across, and nothing beats 17.

Why Does It Work?

Both plans start the same way (Rocket and Jogger cross, Rocket runs back, which takes 2 + 1 = 3 minutes), and both include Wanderer's 10-minute crossing. The difference is what happens to Walker.

In the obvious plan, Walker gets a crossing of their own, and Rocket has to run back afterwards: 5 + 1 = 6 minutes.
In the clever plan, Walker rides along with Wanderer for free. The price is that Jogger has to walk the torch back and then cross again with Rocket: 2 + 2 = 4 minutes.

Four is less than six, so the clever plan wins by 2 minutes. In other words, the clever plan sends the two slow walkers together, and uses the two fast walkers as torch ferries.

Does the Clever Plan Always Win?

No! That's what makes this puzzle so sneaky. Change the times and the answer can change too.

Try a group that takes 1, 3, 4 and 5 minutes:

Obvious plan: 3 + 1 + 4 + 1 + 5 = 14 minutes
Clever plan: 3 + 1 + 5 + 3 + 3 = 15 minutes

This time the obvious plan is faster. The only way to know is to work out both and compare.

Try It Yourself

Three friends. Rocket (1), Jogger (2) and Walker (5) want to cross. What's the fastest time?

A new group. Four friends take 1, 2, 5 and 8 minutes. Work out both plans. Which one wins, and by how much?

Your own friends. Make up four crossing times where the obvious plan wins, and four where the clever plan wins.

Check your answers: for three friends, Rocket and Jogger cross (2), Rocket returns (1), Rocket and Walker cross (5), which makes 8 minutes. For 1, 2, 5 and 8, the obvious plan takes 2 + 1 + 5 + 1 + 8 = 17 minutes and the clever plan takes 2 + 1 + 8 + 2 + 2 = 15 minutes, so the clever plan wins by 2.

The OddMaths Takeaway

Grabbing the best-looking move at every step doesn't always give the best result overall. Sometimes you need to spend a little time now (like sending the slowest two together) to save more later.

It's a trick worth remembering whenever you plan a route or pack a car: the obvious plan is often fine, but it's worth checking whether there's a cleverer one.

🎯 Test Your Skill

Four friends, one torch. Don't drop it.