Here is a mind-reading trick that works every time, and you don't need any mind-reading powers. You only need to know about the number 9.
Ask a friend to follow these steps in secret:
1. Write down any number with several digits, like 7352.
2. Scramble the digits to make a different number, like 2753.
3. Subtract the smaller from the larger: 7352 − 2753 = 4599.
4. Circle any digit of the answer that is not zero, say the 5 in 4599.
5. Read out the other digits (4, 9 and 9), in any order.
Without seeing a thing, you say: "You circled a 5!"
How? The numbers they chose were secret. Take a moment to think about it.
Stop and Think
Hint 1: Add up the digits you were told: 4 + 9 + 9 = 22. Is 22 close to a number in the 9 times table?
Hint 2: The 9 times table goes 9, 18, 27, 36... What is the next one after 22?
Hint 3: What would you need to add to 22 to get to it?
The Trick
The next number in the 9 times table after 22 is 27. And 27 − 22 = 5. That's the circled digit!
Here is the rule:
Add up the digits you hear. Find how far that is from the next number in the 9 times table. That's the hidden digit.
(If the digits you hear already add up to a multiple of 9, the hidden digit is 9.)
There are two things to ask of your friend. They should never circle a 0, because 0 and 9 would look the same to the rule. And if their number contains a 0, they should not put it first when they scramble (so 7350 can become 5037, but not 0357).
Why Does It Work?
There are two secrets, and both are about 9.
Secret 1: a number is "a bunch of 9s plus its digit sum". Think about place values:
10 = 9 + 1
100 = 99 + 1
1000 = 999 + 1
Each of 9, 99 and 999 is in the 9 times table. So any number is a multiple of 9, plus its digits added together. For example:
4725 = (a multiple of 9) + (4 + 7 + 2 + 5) = (a multiple of 9) + 18
That means a number and its digit sum leave the same remainder when you divide by 9.
Secret 2: scrambling keeps the digit sum. If you rearrange the digits, the digit sum doesn't change. So 7352 and 2753 both have a digit sum of 17, and they leave the same remainder when divided by 9.
Put the two secrets together. Two numbers with the same remainder differ by an exact multiple of 9. So the difference, 4599, must be in the 9 times table. Check: 4599 ÷ 9 = 511. And the digits of any number in the 9 times table add up to a multiple of 9: 4 + 5 + 9 + 9 = 27.
That's why the missing digit is easy to find. The digits must add to 9, 18, 27 or so on, and you know all but one of them.
(We tested this on every four-digit number and all of its scrambles, about 158,000 pairs, and on 200,000 random numbers of 3 to 10 digits. The difference was always a multiple of 9.)
Try It Yourself
Do the trick. Pick 9531 and scramble it to 1359. Subtract, and hide the digit 7 from the answer. Can you find it from the other digits?
Your own number. Make up your own number, scramble it and check that the difference is in the 9 times table.
What if the circled digit is 0? Try the trick when the hidden digit is a 0. Why can't you tell it from a 9?
Check your answers: 9531 − 1359 = 8172. The other digits are 8, 1, 2, which add up to 11, and the next multiple of 9 is 18. 18 − 11 = 7, the hidden digit. If the circled digit were 0, the other digits would already add up to a multiple of 9, and a hidden 9 would look exactly the same.
The OddMaths Takeaway
Our brains expect scrambling digits to make a random mess. Instead, the 9 times table sneaks in every time, because writing numbers in tens makes 9 a very special number.
And this is a good trick to have in your pocket: it feels like magic, and the explanation is only a few lines long.